What's the best use of drones during large scale incidents?

Cognitive Work Systems
Pickerington, Ohio
EngineeringPsychology
$204
Raised of $1,835 Goal
12%
Ended on 7/16/16
Campaign Ended
  • $204
    pledged
  • 12%
    funded
  • Finished
    on 7/16/16

About This Project

Emergency responders are starting to use live video from drones to help them assess large-scale disasters. My goal is to help them make the most of this new resource. The first step in doing this is to understand their decision making process and how they use the information that is currently available. This will enable me to determine how introducing this new source of information will impact the cognitive work being performed during an incident.

Ask the Scientists

Join The Discussion

What is the context of this research?

Using drones to assess and monitor an incident scene holds the promise of faster, better organized, and better executed responses to large-scale disasters without risking lives and at a lower cost than traditional means.

Unfortunately no one has yet done a systematic analysis of how this new capability can complement current practices. A preliminary study that I conducted at The Ohio State University suggested that this new resource can actually have negative side effects if it is not employed properly. Part of the issue was that the ICs over relied on what they could see in the video and neglected other important information. This work clearly needs to be followed up if we are to make the most of drones in emergency management.


What is the significance of this project?

The results of this study will help the Emergency Management community understand how they can best leverage drones and the aerial video they provide to support their planning and decision making.

Currently the video from drones is shown on a simple video monitor with
little or no other supporting information. This means that the users
must perform the cognitive work of orienting and integrating the video with other displays and sources information, or as indicated in the previous study, become preoccupied with the video feed.

The key to doing this will be to understand when and where live video can compliment currently available sources of information as part of an integrated decision support and planning system.

What are the goals of the project?

My first goal is to understand the current practices, strategies, and information needs of ICs as they assess, monitor, and respond to an incident.

To prepare for this I will attend advanced classes on Emergency Management that will build on the courses that I attended before the earlier study. I will also travel to observe ICs multiple live fire training exercises.

My next goal is to conduct a Cognitive Task Analysis in order to understand how they organize and structure the information they receive including when and why they access a particular source of information. One of the most common methods of CTA is a structured, in-depth interview with experienced practitioners. I will conduct a series of interviews with ICs who will collaborate with me on this project.

Budget

Please wait...

Part of the funds will cover travel expenses to training classes and live fire exercises that will be held at different locations across Ohio. While the classes themselves are free, all travel expenses are my responsibility.

The majority of the funds will be used to compensate Incident Commanders for their valuable time consulting on this project. I am hoping to recruit at least four experienced ICs and conduct a total of 16 hours of interviews.

This is the first stage of a larger project. The next stage will be the development of a display that will integrate aerial video into an Incident Command decision support system. The final stage will be to test the display and system during training simulations with Incident Commanders.

Any additional funds received during this campaign will go towards funding of Stages 2 and 3.

I hope you will join me on this project to support firefighters and Incident Commanders in their vital work.

Meet the Team

John McGuirl, Ph.D.
John McGuirl, Ph.D.
Cognitive Systems Engineer

Affiliates

Cognitive Systems Analytics
View Profile

John McGuirl, Ph.D.

I recieved my Ph.D. in Cognitive Systems Engineering at The Ohio State University in 2008. In the past I have worked on projects for NASA, the FAA, and the Army Research Laboratory on various issues in human-machine coordination, trust in automation, and how new forms of data impact decision-making.

Like most people in science and research, I've always been interested in knowing how things work. As a kid I was great at taking everything apart, although admittedly not always successful at putting them back together in working order again.

My first career was in telecommunications and testing new networks and systems. I became fascinated with how the technicians at the 'central offices' monitored the overall health and performance of these large networks. As it turns out, the interfaces they used were terrible from a human factors standpoint. Lots and lots of screens with lines of data scrolling by which left the technicians to piece together the 'big picture' of what was really going on. I thought there must be a better way to do it and made a career change.

Today I specialize in understanding what are called socio-technical systems. Socio-technical systems arise anywhere you have people using technology to accomplish their goals while dealing with the complexity of their work environment. These systems are all around us and you are probably working in one yourself. Areas such as aviation, healthcare, the military, and power plants are just a few examples.

I am currently an independent researcher and I'm passionate about helping first responders perform better while minimizing the risks involved in their vital work.


Project Backers

  • 3Backers
  • 12%Funded
  • $204Total Donations
  • $68.00Average Donation
Please wait...