"My God, Why Hast Thou Forsaken Me?" Religious Persecution and the Irish Famine

$276
Raised of $2,100 Goal
14%
Ended on 5/27/18
Campaign Ended
  • $276
    pledged
  • 14%
    funded
  • Finished
    on 5/27/18

About This Project

What will you leave behind when you die? A diary? A blog? A "Remembering (name here)" Facebook page? What if you couldn't read or write? After the British occupation of Ireland, Catholics weren't allowed to go to school, and most never learned to write. A story was told of their superb health, but was that story's true? How can one be healthy when starving? Your contribution will help them tell their own stories through their bones in a skeletal analysis of health before the Famine.

Ask the Scientists

Join The Discussion

What is the context of this research?

The Great Famine marks one of the most significant events in Irish history (Geber 2015:2). While it is often assumed that these events kill indiscriminately, recent studies in bioarchaeology have shown that these disasters are selective (DeWitte 2010, 2014), killing individuals who are most frail. It is therefore possible that underlying health prior to the Famine could have contributed to the catastrophic mortality. Between the late medieval (AD 1250-1550) and post-medieval periods (AD 1550-1880), England intensified its colonization efforts in Ireland to prevent the spread of Catholicism, a perceived threat to the British monarchy. Such efforts could have resulted in adverse health outcomes for the Irish, making them more vulnerable to death.

What is the significance of this project?

My research challenges the assumption that Irish health improved in the post-medieval period (e.g., Clark and Kelly 2010:110, Novak et al. 2017) despite endemic destitution and increasing reliance on the potato. Sinclair (1828), for example, writes that potatoes were a “blessing” and that they had greatly improved the condition of the poor. This project will contribute to Irish history by testing the veracity of such statements. Moreover, if it is found that health declined during this period, this would suggest that underlying population frailty contributed to death during the Famine because poor health in one generation can contribute to poor health in subsequent generations (Gowland, 2015), ultimately increasing risk of death when faced with famine.

What are the goals of the project?

I am testing the veracity of modern narratives and contemporary accounts of Irish health by conducting a bioarchaeological analysis of stress lines in teeth (LEH) and age-at-death in Irish skeletons. Both childhood stress and younger age-at-death are associated with poorer health. I expect that health will have declined during the post-medieval period and that the individuals from this period will exhibit a greater number of LEH and a lower age-at-death. I will test this hypothesis by making casts of teeth and bringing the casts back to the US to examine them under a microscope. This will allow me to count the number of stress lines in the teeth. While I am in Ireland, I will evaluate the age of skeletons in both samples.

Budget

Please wait...

Your contribution will help me pay for my airfare to and from Ireland, which is required so that I can examine about 400 skeletons at the National Museum. University regulations require me to have supplementary health insurance, which is $3 a day for 40 weeks. Finally, your contribution will help me buy materials to make impressions and casts of their teeth. This will allow me to count stress lines, called LEH, which form during childhood when a child is sick or poorly nourished. These illnesses could have affected adult health, making the population more vulnerable to death during the Famine.

Endorsed by

I am currently a bioarchaeology PhD student who has excavated in Ireland. As such, I believe that Melissa's project is the direction that bioarchaeology and biological anthropology should be headed. It challenges written history to explore the health of a population that faced adversity that the skeleton may be able to reveal. I am excited to see the outcomes of this research, and how it can be used to answer more questions in the future.

Flag iconProject Timeline

I will begin skeletal analysis on August 1st in Dublin, Ireland and will stay until April. During this time, I will make observations and take dental casts of 338 skeletons and conduct research in the National Archives. Upon my return to the US in April of 2019, I will examine casts of the teeth under a measuring microscope to count the number of stress lines per individual and compare these between populations. I will defend my dissertation in 2020.

Apr 27, 2018

Project Launched

Aug 01, 2018

Travel to Swords, Co. Dublin, Ireland for research at the Collections Resource Centre

Apr 01, 2019

Return to the US to begin microscopic analysis and continue writing

May 01, 2020

Defend dissertation

Dec 01, 2020

Publish results in academic journal

Meet the Team

Melissa Clark
Melissa Clark

Melissa Clark

I am a bioarchaeologist and PhD candidate at The Ohio State University. Every summer I have worked on an archaeology site in Ireland since 2010. I earned two bachelor's degrees at OSU in 2013, one in Anthropology with research distinction, and the other in International Studies. In 2015 I earned my MSc. in Osteology and Paleopathology from the University of Bradford, UK. When I'm not excavating in Ireland, I am at home in the US mentoring undergraduate students and guiding them through their own independent research projects. My research interests include dental anthropology, bioarchaeology, forensic anthropology, and education pedagogy. I hope to be a professor so that I can continue to help young women and other underrepresented groups in academia follow their dreams, like my advisor has done for me.


Project Backers

  • 7Backers
  • 14%Funded
  • $276Total Donations
  • $39.43Average Donation
Please wait...