Ask the ScientistsJoin The Discussion 〉
What is the context of this research?
Sharks are ecologically and economically important animals whose presence helps keep ocean ecosystems in balance.They keep prey populations in check as well as remove the weak and diseased individuals, promoting balance in the oceans. They also add beauty and diversity to our oceans, which attracts divers from all around the world to popular diving sites. - Unfortunately, due to decades of overfishing on a global scale, many species of sharks have experienced rapid and severe population declines, with some declines surpassing 90% since the 1970’s. One in six known species of sharks, skates, rays, and chimeras are considered Threatened with extinction by the IUCN Red List.
Why feeding ecology?
An emerging trend in marine conservation is “ecosystem based fisheries management,” which means that managers would consider the diet and food web interactions of species of interest. An effective ecosystem-based fisheries management plan, which the U.S. government has expressed interest in instituting, requires detailed diet and food web interactions data. The traditional method of determining diet is called stomach content analysis, and it often consists of cutting open the stomach of animals to see what they’ve eaten. While direct and effective, this type of lethal sampling is inappropriate for threatened species. We will be using an alternative non-lethal method called “stable isotope analysis”.
The basic principles behind stable isotope analysis is that as a predator eats prey, atoms of that prey are incorporated into the predator’s tissues through the process of digestion, which means that on an atomic level, you really are what you eat. Different isotopes (same number of protons, different number of neutrons, so they’re the same element but have a different mass) of certain elements are preferentially retained by certain metabolic processes in a predictable, stepwise pattern. This means that we can measure the diet and habitat usage of animals by comparing their average isotopic ratio (heavy isotope to “normal” isotope) with that of their environment or potential prey.
What is the significance of this project?
Stable isotope analysis is based on the principle that “you are what you eat.” Atoms from digested prey are incorporated into the predator’s tissues, and by tracing naturally occurring radioactivity, we can measure a shark’s diet non-lethally. It’s explained in more detail in this review paper we wrote (LINK). There are a variety of feeding ecology research questions important for creating an ecosystem-based management plan that can be answered with stable isotope analysis. We will be using isotopic ratios of carbon (C13) and nitrogen (N15) from several non-lethally obtained shark tissue samples, including blood, fin, and muscle.
Isotopic ratios of nitrogen reveal the "trophic level," what step of the food chain an animal is on. Isotopic ratios of carbon reveal the "base resource pool," which can tell you if the animal is feeding primarily in a benthic (bottom) vs. pelagic (water column or in a offshore vs. onshore food chain. Taken together, they can provide a good overall look at a local food web. Additionally, a variety of analytical tools exist to help calculate the relative diet breadth of different species, revealing if the species is a generalist or specialist predator, as well as to what extent the species' diet overlaps with other species. All of this is critical information for making an effective conservation and management plan.
These research questions are reviewed in more detail (including examples) in this blog post (LINK).
What are the goals of the project?
We have already collected hundreds of biological samples from over a dozen species of sharks. It costs approximately $10 to process one tissue sample for carbon and nitrogen stable isotopes. 100% of funds raised for this project will be used to cover sample processing fees, and while $3,000 is the minimum we’d need to do this project properly, any additional funds raised would also be applied towards sample processing.
Research questions include:
1) What are the diet and trophic levels (step in the food chain) of coastal shark species in Florida?
2) Do diets and trophic levels change as sharks get older and larger?
3) How broad is the diet of coastal shark species?
4) How much overlap is there between the diets of different species?